Restate or Rewrite?: Stark Choice Faces ALI Leaders on Liability Insurance Law Project

rockThe debate over the American Law Institute’s (ALI) still ongoing Restatement of the Law: Liability Insurance (RLLI) project the mythical struggles of Sisyphus. Since 2015, when ALI—in unprecedented fashion—shifted the venture from an aspirational “Principles Project” to a Restatement, stakeholders and a growing number of third parties concerned with the project’s direction have been pushing the proverbial rock up the hill.

Throughout the drafting process, concerns have been consistently raised that multiple RLLI sections either depart from settled insurance-liability principles or establish entirely new rules. Each time, the RLLI’s Reporters issued a new draft that was nearly identical to the last.

With the release of Council Draft No. 4 for discussion at a January 18, 2018 conclave of the ALI Council—a final step in the approval process before the group’s May annual meeting—the uphill resistance has resumed and intensified. What transpires over the next week could have a profound impact not only on the insurance liability system and its stakeholders, but on ALI itself. Continue reading “Restate or Rewrite?: Stark Choice Faces ALI Leaders on Liability Insurance Law Project”