Activist Ad on High Court Peddles Misleading Propaganda

Capitalizing on the excitement surrounding the looming vacancy on the Supreme Court, three activist groups today used an advertisement in the Washington Post to offer a biting criticism of the Supreme Court’s “corporate-biased” practices.

Unfortunately, despite appearing in a publication of high repute, the ad by Alliance for Justice, MoveOn.Org, and People For The American Way is light on facts and heavy on unsubstantiated criticism.

Consider its claim that the Supreme Court has allowed corporations to “dodg[e] liability for faulty medical devices.”  The quotation alludes to Riegel v. Medtronic in which the eight justice majority declared that federal law preempts state common-law claims.  This opinion does not represent a renegade court; rather, it is in keeping with The Medical Device Amendments, drafted in 1976, which expressly allow federal preemption.  Federal preemption is not a whim of the Supreme Court, but the will of the people as represented by our legislators in Congress.

Or consider the ad’s claim that the Court is led by “the radical right … Justices Roberts and Alito.”  It is true that John Roberts is the Chief Justice, but it is also true that Roberts was confirmed with a good deal of bipartisan support—something a true “radical” could certainly not have achieved. Continue reading

Last Week at WLF

New Publications:

New Report Finds Stunning Erosion of Criminal Intent Requirements in Federal Law

Guest Commentary

Cynthia Hujar OrrPresident, National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers

 Honoring Law Day 2010: Enduring Traditions, Emerging Challenges, the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers (NACDL) and the Heritage Foundation this week challenged Congress with the release of our joint report and recommendations, Without Intent: How Congress Is Eroding the Criminal Intent Requirement in Federal Law. This report was the product of tremendous research by both organizations, and we are confident it will serve as an important blueprint for legislative reform.

In a joint press conference on Capitol Hill on Wednesday, May 5, Rep. Bobby Scott (D-VA) and Rep. Louie Gohmert (R-TX), the Chairman and Ranking Member of the House Crime Subcommittee, respectively, sponsored the release of this groundbreaking, non-partisan report. NACDL Executive Director Norman Reimer and Former Attorney General Edwin Meese also spoke. Continue reading